Christmas Brownies Fudgy Recipe 6 Ways

18. December 2020

Prep time: 2 hours

Serves: 15

This is probably the easiest holiday treats recipe for kids and grown-ups: this Christmas Brownies fudgy recipe. It is a delicious fudge brownies recipe, decorated like a flat Christmas tree cake, a Christmas present cake, reindeer cake, snowman cake, Santa hat cake or Christmas baubles cake. For all of these we need almost the same toppings and they make up the best and beautiful pops and bites for everyone.

  • You can see the entire step by step baking process in my Instagram Highlights. It would be great to also see you there, you can follow me to always stay up to date with all my baking stories.
  • For more extraordinary cake recipes, check out my celebration & creative cakes section.

Easy Recipe for Christmas Decorated Brownies

This Christmas cake recipe is super easy and straight forward. For a fudgy chocolate brownies recipe it is not needed to whip the cake batter that much. First, we carefully melt the butter and in it the chocolate pieces. Melting chocolate should always be done carefully, because high temperatures will separate the components of chocolate, but when putting chocolate in a cake batter it is not that bad as it all will be baked. Second, we mix in the sugar and salt to the butter chocolate mixture. Every single egg is added separately and shortly mixed into the cake batter. Last but not least we add flour.

These chocolate fudge brownies are spread on a 20x30cm / 9×13 inch inch baking tray and baked at 175°C / 350°F for 20-25 minutes. Importantly, to not bake those for too long, otherwise they’ll become dry and lose their fudginess.

Christmas Cake Decoration Ideas

This Christmas brownies fudgy recipe is variable and I am presenting here a couple of ideas on how to make Christmas brownies:

  • Christmas Tree Brownies: to make the brownies Christmas like we use regular cream cheese frosting, spread it on the chocolate Christmas tree brownies, stick a candy cane, Mikado or pretzel as tree stump in it and decorated with M&M’s and sprinkles
  • Christmas Gift Brownies: spreading the white cream cheese frosting on it and with red or green colored frosting and M&M’s the details are made for the Christmas decorated brownies
  • Reindeer Brownies: for this fudgy recipe we use pretzels for the antler, white frosting and chocolate for the eyes and red M&M’s for the nose
  • Snowman Brownies: we spread white frosting on the fudgy brownies, pretzels are used for the nose, and for the hat we dunk a pretzel in chocolate and form the rest of the hat and eyes with the chocolate as well
  • Santa Hat Brownies: spreading red and white frosting on the brownies
  • Christmas Baubles Brownies: we spread either white, red or green cream cheese frosting on the homemade fudge brownies and decorate them with whatever we have!

These are all only recommendations end everyone’s creativity is so unique that I am happy when you find your own way of decorating the brownies.


How To Cut Christmas Tree Brownies

In order to obtain perfect triangles to decorate the brownies we need a diagram for cutting Christmas tree brownies. I’ll show you in simple steps how to cut brownies. First we cut the chocolate brownies in stripes, each stripe with a width of about 5cm /2 inch. Then cut diagonal from one edge of the brownies to the other side, but not to the other edge but to the middle of the cake. Mirroring this cut, we can cut a couple of stripe paralleling this cut. And then repeat the last step with the other diagonal. This should result in slim triangle which are perfect for Christmas tree brownies, reindeer brownies, Santa hat brownies and snowman brownies.

Christmas Brownies Recipe

For the Christmas baubles we can just cut circles, using any kind of circle shaped cutter and for the Christmas gift brownies the brownies can be cut in squares. You can view the Christmas tree brownies video and the making of in my Instagram Highlights.

Print Recipe

Christmas Brownies Fudgy Recipe

  • Preparation time: 2 hours
  • Servings: 15

Christmas Fudge Brownies

  • 1 & 1/8 cup (250g) butter
  • 1 & 3/4 cup (300g) dark chocolate
  • 1 & 1/2 cup (300g) sugar
  • 1 pinch salt
  • 4 eggs
  • 1 & 1/2 cup (200g) flour

Frostings & Decorations

  • 1 & 3/4 cup (400g) cream cheese, (room temperature)
  • 1/4 cup (50g) butter, (room temperature)
  • 1/3 cup (40g) powdered sugar
  • 2 tbsp lemon juice
  • 1/2 cup (100g) dark chocolate
  • Decorations: green & red food coloring, M&Ms, candy cane, Mikado, sprinkles, sugar pens, mikado


Christmas Fudge Brownies

    1. Melt the butter together with the dark chocolate. Don’t expose it to high temperatures, melting should always be done carefully.
    2. Add the sugar and salt and stir in with a whisk. Mix in every egg individually until combined.
    3. Finally fold in the flour and spread the cake batter into a 20x30cm / 9×13 inch cake pan or on a parchment paper which is cut into the size respectively. Bake at 175°C / 350°F for approx. 20-25 minutes.
    4. Cut the dough as shown in this diagram:

    Diagram-for cutting-how-to-cut-Christmas-tree-brownies-Schneiden-Vorlage

Frostings & Decorations

  • 5. Mix the cream cheese and butter, both at room temperature, with the powdered sugar and lemon juice. Divide into three parts and color one part with green and one part with red food coloring. Fill the red, green and white cream cheese frosting into piping bags and spread the frosting on the fudge brownies as in the picture Decorate with the candy cane, mikado, M&Ms, mini pretzels, sugar pens and sprinkles.

Leave a Reply

Previous Recipe Next Recipe